3,647 rated or chosen profiles from 3,647 respondents, in up to 1 tasks of 1 profile varying on 4 attributes.
One of 3 tables from the same source; this one is the shaming table. The others are listed under Related tables.
| Description | US respondents (n = 3,647; waves 1, 2 and 5) read a vignette about the US government's climate action under the Paris Agreement (laws passed or not, emissions cut, energy price rise) and whether other countries criticized it, and rated their approval overall. |
|---|---|
| Reference | Tingley, D., & Tomz, M. (2021). The effects of naming and shaming on public support for compliance with international agreements: An experimental analysis of the Paris Agreement. International Organization, 76(2), 445-468. |
| DOI | 10.1017/S0020818321000394 |
| Licence | CC0 1.0 |
| Source data | https://doi.org/10.7910/DVN/JVKQLC |
These notes describe the source data, which the IRW reproduces as released. All notes are listed on the Data Notes page.
| Respondents | 3,647 |
|---|---|
| Rows (one per respondent, task and profile) | 3,647 |
| Tasks per respondent (most) | 1 |
| Profiles per task | 1 |
| Attributes | 4 |
| Topic | climate energy environment, foreign policy security |
|---|---|
| A profile represents | scenario |
| Country | US |
| Language shown | en |
| Language of stored levels | en |
| Randomization restrictions | yes (stated by the source): emissions_cut and energy_price exist only when new laws were passed ('(not shown)' otherwise); the criticism wording says 'doing nothing' only when no laws were passed; wave 5 shows only the 25% cut and always criticism; no-laws about 1/3 of respondents in waves 1-2 (shares unequal, no documented probabilities) |
| Task order | inferred from row order |
| Profile position | inferred from row order |
Because the attribute levels were not randomized independently, an estimator has to account for the restriction; a plain difference in means across levels can mislead. Task order or profile position was rebuilt from row order; analyses of position or task order should leave it out.
Outcomes:
| rating | Taking into account all the decisions the U.S. government made in the passage you read, would you approve or disapprove of what U.S. government did overall? [rating, 1 (Approve strongly) to 5 (Disapprove strongly)] |
|---|
attr_emissions_cutattr_energy_priceattr_new_lawsattr_shamingcov_agecov_attention_passcov_educationcov_gendercov_party_id7idprofileratingtasktrial_wave
The layout (one row per respondent, task and profile; choice/rating outcomes; attr_ columns holding each attribute level as displayed) is defined in the IRW conjoint standard. What the outcomes asked is under Design above.
Or load it directly in R (no account needed with irw 1.4.0 or later) or Python (needs a free Redivis account; the first call opens a browser to sign in):
# R
install.packages("irw")
library(irw)
df <- irw_fetch("tingley_2021_paris_shaming", source = "conj")
# Python
pip install irw
import irw
df = irw.fetch("tingley_2021_paris_shaming", source="conj")
Or in Stata, which reads the same no-account CSV as the button above:
* Stata
net install irw, from("https://raw.githubusercontent.com/itemresponsewarehouse/Stata-pkg/main/")
irw_fetch tingley_2021_paris_shaming, clear source(conj)
@article{Tingley_2021, title={The Effects of Naming and Shaming on Public Support for Compliance with International Agreements: An Experimental Analysis of the Paris Agreement}, volume={76}, ISSN={1531-5088}, url={http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0020818321000394}, DOI={10.1017/s0020818321000394}, number={2}, journal={International Organization}, publisher={Cambridge University Press (CUP)}, author={Tingley, Dustin and Tomz, Michael}, year={2021}, month=Sept, pages={445–468} }
| IRW version | v744 |
|---|---|
| Redivis dataset | irw_conjoint_2 v4.0 |
| Redivis dataset DOI | 10.57761/npz5-mq61 |
| Manifest pin for this IRW version | v4.0 |
| Metadata source | irw_meta v78.0 |