210 rated or chosen profiles from 210 respondents, in up to 1 tasks of 1 profile varying on 4 attributes.
| Description | UK Prolific adults (n=210, June 2023) each read one incentivized vignette offering to invest a real GBP 1 through a human expert or an algorithm, with each agent's estimated profit (3% or 21%) and decisional control (automatic vs final say) randomized in a 2x2x2x2 between-subjects design; outcomes are the expert/algorithm pick, a 1-7 relative preference, and a buy/abort decision for those who picked an agent offering control. |
|---|---|
| Reference | Schaap, G., Bosse, T., & Hendriks Vettehen, P. (2023). How users trade off agency and benefits in accepting AI vs human decision-makers. Part 2: Direct choice - incentivized interaction [Data set]. OSF. |
| Licence | CC BY 4.0 |
| Source data | https://osf.io/nwqgs/ |
These notes describe the source data, which the IRW reproduces as released. All notes are listed on the Data Notes page.
| Respondents | 210 |
|---|---|
| Rows (one per respondent, task and profile) | 210 |
| Tasks per respondent (most) | 1 |
| Profiles per task | 1 |
| Attributes | 4 |
| Topic | technology ai privacy |
|---|---|
| A profile represents | product service |
| Country | GB |
| Language shown | en |
| Language of stored levels | en |
| Task order | inferred from row order |
| Profile position | inferred from row order |
Task order or profile position was rebuilt from row order; analyses of position or task order should leave it out.
Outcomes:
| rating | Reviewing the options above, please tell us how strongly you prefer one option over the other for this investment. [rating, 1 (I definitely prefer the expert) to 7 (I definitely prefer the algorithm)] |
|---|---|
| rating_agent | Select your option. Below, you find the two options summarised. THESE are your options, summarised: Please choose your option now [rating, 1 (Option A: Expert) to 2 (Option B: Algorithm)] |
| rating_invest | The investor predicts an 18% rise in stocks of a company called 'XPDA International Group' within the next minutes. Please indicate whether you agree with making the proposed investment. [rating, 1 (BUY! Notice: The transaction will be performed immediately.) to 8 (ABORT! Notice: No investment will be made.)] |
attr_algorithm_benefitattr_algorithm_controlattr_expert_benefitattr_expert_controlcov_background_cscov_background_financecov_birth_yearcov_duration_seccov_educationcov_genderidprofileratingrating_agentrating_investtasktrial_mc_benefittrial_mc_control
The layout (one row per respondent, task and profile; choice/rating outcomes; attr_ columns holding each attribute level as displayed) is defined in the IRW conjoint standard. What the outcomes asked is under Design above.
Or load it directly in R (no account needed with irw 1.4.0 or later) or Python (needs a free Redivis account; the first call opens a browser to sign in):
# R
install.packages("irw")
library(irw)
df <- irw_fetch("schaap_2023_ai_agency_incentivized", source = "conj")
# Python
pip install irw
import irw
df = irw.fetch("schaap_2023_ai_agency_incentivized", source="conj")
Or in Stata, which reads the same no-account CSV as the button above:
* Stata
net install irw, from("https://raw.githubusercontent.com/itemresponsewarehouse/Stata-pkg/main/")
irw_fetch schaap_2023_ai_agency_incentivized, clear source(conj)
@dataset{Schaap2023,
author = {Schaap, G. and Bosse, T. and {Hendriks Vettehen}, P.},
title = {How users trade off agency and benefits in accepting {AI} vs human decision-makers. {P}art 2: {D}irect choice - incentivized interaction},
year = {2023},
publisher = {OSF},
url = {https://osf.io/nwqgs/}
}
| IRW version | v744 |
|---|---|
| Redivis dataset | irw_conjoint v5.0 |
| Redivis dataset DOI | 10.57761/x788-4838 |
| Manifest pin for this IRW version | v5.0 |
| Metadata source | irw_meta v78.0 |