schaap_2023_ai_agency_incentivized

210 rated or chosen profiles from 210 respondents, in up to 1 tasks of 1 profile varying on 4 attributes.

About this table

DescriptionUK Prolific adults (n=210, June 2023) each read one incentivized vignette offering to invest a real GBP 1 through a human expert or an algorithm, with each agent's estimated profit (3% or 21%) and decisional control (automatic vs final say) randomized in a 2x2x2x2 between-subjects design; outcomes are the expert/algorithm pick, a 1-7 relative preference, and a buy/abort decision for those who picked an agent offering control.
ReferenceSchaap, G., Bosse, T., & Hendriks Vettehen, P. (2023). How users trade off agency and benefits in accepting AI vs human decision-makers. Part 2: Direct choice - incentivized interaction [Data set]. OSF.
LicenceCC BY 4.0
Source datahttps://osf.io/nwqgs/

Notes

These notes describe the source data, which the IRW reproduces as released. All notes are listed on the Data Notes page.

Size and shape

Respondents210
Rows (one per respondent, task and profile)210
Tasks per respondent (most)1
Profiles per task1
Attributes4

Design

Topictechnology ai privacy
A profile representsproduct service
CountryGB
Language shownen
Language of stored levelsen
Task orderinferred from row order
Profile positioninferred from row order

Task order or profile position was rebuilt from row order; analyses of position or task order should leave it out.

Outcomes:

ratingReviewing the options above, please tell us how strongly you prefer one option over the other for this investment. [rating, 1 (I definitely prefer the expert) to 7 (I definitely prefer the algorithm)]
rating_agentSelect your option. Below, you find the two options summarised. THESE are your options, summarised: Please choose your option now [rating, 1 (Option A: Expert) to 2 (Option B: Algorithm)]
rating_investThe investor predicts an 18% rise in stocks of a company called 'XPDA International Group' within the next minutes. Please indicate whether you agree with making the proposed investment. [rating, 1 (BUY! Notice: The transaction will be performed immediately.) to 8 (ABORT! Notice: No investment will be made.)]

Columns

attr_algorithm_benefitattr_algorithm_controlattr_expert_benefitattr_expert_controlcov_background_cscov_background_financecov_birth_yearcov_duration_seccov_educationcov_genderidprofileratingrating_agentrating_investtasktrial_mc_benefittrial_mc_control

The layout (one row per respondent, task and profile; choice/rating outcomes; attr_ columns holding each attribute level as displayed) is defined in the IRW conjoint standard. What the outcomes asked is under Design above.

Get the data

Download CSVno account neededBrowse on Redivisexplore and queryCroissant metadataHugging Face, Kaggle, OpenML

Or load it directly in R (no account needed with irw 1.4.0 or later) or Python (needs a free Redivis account; the first call opens a browser to sign in):

# R
install.packages("irw")
library(irw)
df <- irw_fetch("schaap_2023_ai_agency_incentivized", source = "conj")
# Python
pip install irw

import irw
df = irw.fetch("schaap_2023_ai_agency_incentivized", source="conj")

Or in Stata, which reads the same no-account CSV as the button above:

* Stata
net install irw, from("https://raw.githubusercontent.com/itemresponsewarehouse/Stata-pkg/main/")

irw_fetch schaap_2023_ai_agency_incentivized, clear source(conj)

How to cite

@dataset{Schaap2023,
  author = {Schaap, G. and Bosse, T. and {Hendriks Vettehen}, P.},
  title = {How users trade off agency and benefits in accepting {AI} vs human decision-makers. {P}art 2: {D}irect choice - incentivized interaction},
  year = {2023},
  publisher = {OSF},
  url = {https://osf.io/nwqgs/}
}

Version and provenance

IRW versionv744
Redivis datasetirw_conjoint v5.0
Redivis dataset DOI10.57761/x788-4838
Manifest pin for this IRW versionv5.0
Metadata sourceirw_meta v78.0