haas_2023_group_leader

1,101 marked positions from 367 rankers over 3 options.

One of 12 tables from the same source. The others are listed under Related tables.

About this table

DescriptionSurvey ranking question: full 1-3 ranking of the three members of a real-money group as ideal leader (self, another Hindu member, a Muslim member), Hindu respondents only (cov_treat: 0 neutral, 1 exclusive, 2 inclusive history). The raw file stores the two partners' reverse-coded demand scores and PRD derives the respondent's own position as the remaining rank; Muslim respondents' mirror task is not in PRD. 367 respondents, 3 ranked items, 3 rank positions used, 1101 rows. One row per respondent x marked position; item = the option as the source prints it, resp = the position recorded (1 = most preferred). Standardised by the Political Rankings Database (Atsusaka & Singh 2026) from the authors' replication deposit; rankings layout (data/rankings/README.md).
ReferenceHaas, N. & Lindstam, E. 2023. 'My History or Our History? Historical Revisionism and Entitlement to Lead.' American Political Science Review 118(4). Standardised in Atsusaka, Y. & Singh, S. (2026). Ranking Data in Political Science [database]. Political Rankings Database. https://political-rankings.github.io
LicenceCC0 1.0
Source datahttps://political-rankings.github.io

These data were found via the Political Rankings Database, where the study's standardised ranking file and its codebook are available.

Notes

These notes describe the source data, which the IRW reproduces as released. All notes are listed on the Data Notes page.

Size and shape

Items3
Rankers367
Marked positions (one row each)1,101
Rankings per respondent1
Counting methodsurvey
Positions offered3
Candidates3
Ballots cast367
Ballots with marks367
Duplicate marks0
Overvotes0
Write-ins0
Write-in allowedno
Candidate orderunknown
JurisdictionIndia (lab-in-the-field group decision game)
Contest dateunknown
Officefull 1-3 ranking of the three members of a real-money group as ideal leader (self, another Hindu member, a Muslim member), Hindu respondents only (cov_treat: 0 neutral, 1 exclusive, 2 inclusive history). The raw file stores the two partners' reverse-coded demand scores and PRD derives the respondent's own position as the remaining rank; Muslim respondents' mirror task is not in PRD

Columns

cov_agecov_castecov_castecategorycov_citycov_compcov_comp2cov_educationcov_educationhighcov_gendercov_interest_polcov_roundcov_schooltypecov_statecov_state_seccov_treatcov_urbanruralcov_year_gradiditemresptask

The layout (one row per respondent, ranking and marked position; resp the position as recorded, 1 = first choice; item a candidate code c01, c02, … or a reserved value) is defined in the IRW rankings standard. Skipped positions are gaps and duplicate marks are kept, so compress with irw_rank_compress() / irw.rank_compress() before a person-by-item pivot.

Get the data

Download CSVno account neededBrowse on Redivisexplore and queryCroissant metadataHugging Face, Kaggle, OpenML

Or load it directly in R (no account needed with irw 1.4.0 or later) or Python (needs a free Redivis account; the first call opens a browser to sign in):

# R
install.packages("irw")
library(irw)
df <- irw_fetch("haas_2023_group_leader", source = "rank")
# Python
pip install irw

import irw
df = irw.fetch("haas_2023_group_leader", source="rank")

Or in Stata, which reads the same no-account CSV as the button above:

* Stata
net install irw, from("https://raw.githubusercontent.com/itemresponsewarehouse/Stata-pkg/main/")

irw_fetch haas_2023_group_leader, clear source(rank)

How to cite

@misc{https://doi.org/10.7910/dvn/f8srta,
  doi = {10.7910/DVN/F8SRTA},
  url = {https://dataverse.harvard.edu/citation?persistentId=doi:10.7910/DVN/F8SRTA},
  author = {Haas, Nicholas and Lindstam, Emmy},
  keywords = {Social Sciences, historical revisionism, national identity, minority politics, leader emergence, representation},
  title = {Replication Data for: My History or Our History? Historical Revisionism and Entitlement to Lead},
  publisher = {Harvard Dataverse},
  year = {2023}
}

This table was found via PRD; please also cite:

@misc{atsusaka2026prd, title={Ranking Data in Political Science}, author={Atsusaka, Yuki and Singh, Shubhangi}, year={2026}, howpublished={Political Rankings Database}, url={https://political-rankings.github.io}}

Version and provenance

IRW versionv744
Redivis datasetirw_rank v2.1
Redivis dataset DOI10.57761/fznb-zb47
Manifest pin for this IRW versionv2.1
Metadata sourceirw_meta v78.0